Skip to main content
Real Home Value Calculator: Assessed Value vs Market Value,, Mammoth Lakes

Understanding a home’s true market value is about more than pictures, software assessments, and price-per-square-foot. Whether you’re a current homeowner thinking of selling or are house-hunting, it’s crucial you understand what factors affect home valuation. By partnering with a local market expert, sellers will avoid pricing their house out of the market (the kiss of death in real estate) and buyers will ensure they get a good deal on their next home.

So, how do you accurately calculate a home’s value? After all, the value of a home is assigned by its town or county and the one it’s given when it’s listed are often dramatically different from one another. Which one is accurate and what does it all mean? Read on to learn more.

Assessed Value vs Market Value: What’s the difference?

When it comes to home value, you’ll often hear two terms, assessed value and market value.

A home’s assessed value is often the lower number of the two and is the value given by your municipality or county. Investopedia defines assessed value as “the dollar value assigned to a property to measure applicable taxes.”1 Although property tax laws vary, assessors commonly arrive at this number by taking into account the following:

  • What comparable/similar homes are selling for in your area.
  • The value of recent improvements.
  • Income from renting out a room or space on the property.
  • How much it would cost to rebuild on the property.

A home’s market value, or Fair Market Value, is the price a buyer is willing to pay or a seller is willing to accept for a property. A skilled real estate professional will arrive at the value using a variety of metrics, including:

  • External characteristics, such as lot size, home style, the condition of the home and curb appeal.
  • Internal characteristics, such as the number of rooms and their size, the type and condition of the heating or HVAC system, the quality and condition of construction, the flow of the home, etc.
  • The sales price of comparable homes that have sold in your area.
  • Supply and demand; that is, how many buyers and sellers are in the area.
  • Location; that is, the quality and desirability of your neighborhood and other community amenities.

Why are these values often so different? An assessor usually estimates your property’s market value during a reassessment or if you make a physical change or improvement to it.2 As a result, a property may not be reassessed for many years. While your home’s market value may fluctuate with the market, your home’s assessed value is more likely to remain steady.3

What Determines a Home’s Value?

You’ve likely heard the motto of real estate: “Location, location, location.” This means a home’s value relies on its location. While the home and structures on the property will likely depreciate over time, the land beneath it tends to appreciate. Why? Land is in limited supply and a growing population puts increased demand on the housing supply. As a result, values increase.4

Other factors that affect your home’s value include the function and appearance of the property, how well the home and other structures are maintained and whether the home is a lifestyle property, such as a ranch style with mountain views or beach bungalow.

Ultimately, the best indication of a home’s value is the overall supply and demand of the market. This is why we recommend you partner with a real estate professional who takes all of these factors—the assessed value, local market conditions, home features and has physically walked through and experienced your home— into consideration to determine the most accurate market value.

How to determine if a property is comparable to yours.

Both assessed value and market value are partially determined by the sales price of similar, or comparable, homes in the area. To determine if a home is comparable to yours, look for the following characteristics:

  • Lot size
  • Square footage
  • Homestyle or similar architecture
  • Age
  • Location

While you may not find a home with the same exact characteristics as yours, you’ll likely find a few that are close. To account for any disparity, adjust the sales prices of the comparable properties. Look at the differences between your property and the one in question and determine if the differences increased or decreased the sales price and by how much. For example, if your home has two bathrooms and a similar home only has three, estimate how much that extra bathroom increased the sale price of the similar home. The adjusted sale price is the estimation of what the property would sell for if the properties were exactly the same.2

Where can you find comparable sales?

Fortunately, you can find comparable home sales in a variety of places.2

  • Your local assessor’s office is able to provide a list of recent sales you can browse and compare or a sales history of a particular house, home style or neighborhood.
  • Your municipality. Many cities keep local sales information in their offices or post it online.
  • Online databases, such as a real estate database
  • Your local newspapers may offer some real estate information in the form of quarterly sales reports in the business or real estate sections of the newspaper.
  • Our office. We regularly do Comparable Market Analysis of homes in our local area.  Use our Home Valuation inquiry form for your home.

How to calculate your home’s value.

By answering a few questions about your home, property and the local market, you can begin to estimate your property’s value. We’ve also included a worksheet for you below…

Home Value Questions:

  • When was your home last assessed?
  • What was its CMA assessment value?
  • What is your area’s average sales price?
  • What is your area’s average price/square foot?


  • Is the architecture and exterior structure of the home consistent, superior or inferior to other homes in the area?
  • Does the era or genre (Modern, Victorian, Ranch, Cottage, etc.) add a premium based on current design trends?
  • How do the floor plan and room size proportions of the home compare to other homes on the market?

Interior Structure:

  • How does the kitchen compare to others on the market?
    • Updated or outdated
    • Floor plan
    • Appliance packages
  • How does the Master Suite compare to others on the market?
    • Size
    • First/second floor
    • Updated or outdated
    • Access to Master Bath
  • How does the Master Bath compare to others on the market?
    • Updated or outdated
    • Shower and bath
    • Flooring

Outside Areas:

  • Are there views, outdoor living areas or recreational areas?
    • Pools
    • Ponds
    • Patios
  • How do the landscaping and hardscaping compare to the market? (e.g., built elements such as walkways, patios, decks, etc.)

Overall Condition of Home

  • What is the level of repair needed to compete with other homes?
  • Does the home need to be staged? How does it show?
  • What curb appeal projects are necessary to be consistent with others on the market?

Home Assessment Worksheet

If you want to accurately assess a home’s value, it’s crucial to know about the market activity of our local area. Sonja can help! Give her a call to get the scoop on the local market at 661-979-9000 or email her at [email protected].

Sources: 1. Investopedia

  1. New York State Department of Taxation and Finance
  3. Investopedia,

Follow Along on Instagram

There are a few different scenarios for homeowners that are struggling to make their mortgage payments or are “underwater” on their homes (and owe more than what it’s worth)—including short sales and foreclosures. While we don’t see many of either in Mammoth Lakes, this may be helpful for those outside the area.

Read More in my blog... Link in Bio...

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate #tipsandtricks

4 0

Make finding your flashlights easier in a power outage by wrapping glow in the dark tape around the handle. I love simple hacks!

Saved me on more than one occasion!

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate #tipsandtricks

2 0

Steps to The Village at Mammoth and Canyon Lodge gondola, this totally updated Westin Monache one-bedroom condo is ready for you to enjoy or start renting out today!
Link in bio...
#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

5 0

And you know what the A in Zillow stands for, right?!

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

9 4

Here are a few reasons buyers should finally be feeling more optimistic. 🌟

Wondering if it’s the right time for you to buy a home? We’d be happy to talk through the specifics of your situation. Send us a DM today! 📲

#sonjasellsmammoth #destinationmammoth #mammothrealtor #mammothcabin #mammothcondo #mammothrealestate #bestagentinmammoth
#homebuyertips #homebuyer #firsttimehomebuyer #realestate #realestateagent

5 1

The Mammoth Lakes Ice Rink is officially open! Come join in even more winter fun! Located near the Mammoth Lakes Library.

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

6 0

Happy Thanksgiving From Beautiful Mammoth Lakes CA!

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

8 0

Have you watched homes on your street sell for sky-high prices in the past few years?

It’s tempting to aim high when it comes time to sell your home—but proceed with caution.

The market is adapting to rising mortgage rates, and homes simply aren’t selling as fast. Unfortunately, the longer a home is listed, the more buyers’ concerns begin to grow.

Of course, you also don’t want to sell your home for less than it’s worth.

That’s why it’s important to work with a local market expert. We know the ins and outs of the local real estate market and what buyers are willing to pay today.

The good news? If you’ve been in your home for several years, you are likely to have a sizable amount of equity. That means you stand to make a tidy profit. 🤑

Get in touch for a free home value assessment to find out what your home could sell for in today’s market!

📲 760.914.4664
📧 [email protected]

#realestatetips #housingmarket #homeowner #homesellers #personalfinance #realestate #realestateagent #homesforsale #realestateinvesting #sellmyhouse #mammothrealestate #sonjasellsmammoth #mammothcabin #mammothlakesrealestate #mammothrealtor #destinationmammoth

2 1

Mammoth Lakes - Best Ski Town!
Exciting news. Mammoth Lakes has been nominated for Best Ski Town in America in the USA Today 2022 10Best Readers’ Choice travel awards. But also, Clocktower Cellar has been nominated for Best Ski Bar!

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate #bestskitown #bestskibar #bestskitownusa

7 0

November Market Update!

Link in Bio...

#mammothlakes #californialife #sierra #easternsierra #mammothlife #vacationliving #mammothlifestyle #dailylife
#sonjasellsmammoth #mammothcondos #mammothrealestate
#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

5 0

While I am often accused of being an eternal optimist, there are some valid reasons for having a positive outlook on the current real estate market.

When you’re hearing news about home prices remaining high, and mortgage rates skyrocketing, you might wonder how a real estate agent can possibly claim it’s a great time to buy. Or, on the other hand, you read that sales prices are coming down and it’s taking longer to sell because rates have gone up, it may make you question how agents can claim that it’s a great time to sell.

You might feel like agents always seem to be constantly putting a positive spin on the current real estate market, and think they’re doing it out of self-interest. After all, they only make money if and when someone buys or sells a house, so of course they’d want people to feel like it’s always a great time to buy or sell real estate.

Link to full article in bio.

1 0

"Sonja was so professional and wonderful to deal with. She stepped in when our original realtor bowed out after we drove 5 hours to look at real estate. She stepped in without a single hiccup and then stood by us as we negotiated the purchase price and was with us helping us get the mortgage. She was a full service realtor even doing things not normally done by a realtor. Highly recommend her."

#mammothlakes #californialife #sierra #easternsierra #mammothlife #vacationliving #mammothlifestyle #dailylife
#sonjasellsmammoth #mammothcondos #mammothrealestate
#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate #testemonial

3 0

Curious about what they are building in town near The Stove restaurant?? A new recreation center is coming to Mammoth Lakes! For more check out my blog...

Link in bio...

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

8 0

Sonja is super excited to help her clients sell their St. Anton condo -- they are doing a 1031 exchange and will be buying in another state. The good news is they still own in Mammoth Lakes and will be around for years to come. A local full time resident is the new owner and will call this place home....just in time for the holidays! Thanks to Lauren Tracey and Sierra Escrow.

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate @side_realestate

6 2

How can you get the most money for your home in today’s market? 💰

The real estate market is cooling. But it’s still possible to score a great offer if you follow these tips:

🛠️ Make strategic repairs and improvements
🧹 Declutter and depersonalize
🛋️ Stage your home for success
🧽 Prep for each showing
💸 Price your home correctly from the start

Searching for more home seller strategies to maximize your sale price? Check out our blog post!


#realestatetips #housingmarket #homeowner #homesellers #personalfinance #realestate #realestateagent #homesforsale #realestateinvesting #sellmyhouse #mammoth #mammothrealestate #mammothlakesrealestate #mammothcabin #mammothrealtor

2 0

Mammoth Holiday Tip:
Morrison's is a great dinner option for the whole family. A fan favorite is the Barrumundi.

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

11 0

895 Canyon Blvd #34
Mammoth Lakes, CA 93546

Stop by and check out this condo right next door to Canyon Lodge!
Saturday, November 19
2 PM - 5:30 PM
Hosted by Destination Real Estate REALTOR® Danielle Bauman

Link in bio...

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

5 0

Save your empty toilet paper rolls and dryer lint for DIY fire starters. Just stuff the tubes with the lint and you've got free kindling for your grill, campfire, or fireplace.

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate #tipsandtricks

4 0

Check out my latest newsletter for all the Mammoth Lakes real estate updates and information!

Link in bio...

#destinationmammoth #destinationrealestate #mammothmountain #monocounty #mammothhomes #monocountytourism #monocountyrealestate

9 0

Let’s Talk

You’ve got questions and we can’t wait to answer them.

We use cookies and tracking technology in connection with your activities on our website. By viewing and using our website, you consent to our use of cookies and tracking technology in accordance with our Privacy Policy.